This is an extremely debatable topic for me, I think every OSU fan knows exactly how much success we’ve had in football in the past 11-12 years however I firmly believe that if we had more conference championships we would not even be debating about which conference we might go or if we can even get into one at all. If anything I would say OSU fans OVERESTIMATE how much those wins actually mean to other people. If you’ve seen the graphic that shows the overall records in the big xII over the last 7-8 years whatever it is and has Texas in 5th or whatever, OSU is in 2nd and to most people outside of the big xII that is a complete shock. I understand it also has A LOT to do with OSU being a small market but you would think a p5 team that is consistently winning or competing in conference championships would have no problem being pulled into the SEC or BIG.
Well, it's too much of a rabbit hole to really get into it, and I don't really blame those outside of our state for not realizing it, but over recent years I've consistently seen examples of our fans underestimating the quality of the teams we've fielded in the Gundy era. The replies in this very thread are strongly weighted towards the 'not realizing we are
comfortably a top 25 team mentality. ...which is why it felt like a particularly appropriate time for me to bring it up. And I'd bet a ton of fans on this board would be surprised about that stat I mentioned (that puts us in the company of the biggest programs in football).
I don't know what to say about your statement that, if anything, OSU fans overestimate the importance of their won-loss record. If that's been your experience, it's pretty hard for me to believe, but I guess only you can speak to that.
But I do agree that the lack of conference championships, aka beating OU, is factoring into the mentality I'm talking about. I also figure some fans have a long history with this team that tints their vision, whereas I only started paying attention when I became a student after Gundy was hired. Relatively speaking, all my OSU experience has been winning.