Official Game Thread: Oklahoma State vs. Iowa State

[llcoolw]

If you mean that all the other games would still be up for grabs, then KU has to be last, because if we lose to them, we're losing all the other games too.
ksu, TT, WVU, TCU, ISU, BU, OU, TX, KU

I suppose my point about KU would apply in the opposite sense to OU, and also strategically, I guess you wouldn't want to lose to a team you might be in a tight race with to make the CCG, both of which would probably push teams like ISU and BU in front of OU for 'least acceptable to lose to', but I cherry picked not to factor that in.

I ordered mine based on hate. And ku isn’t hated but I don’t want to lose to them either. I stand by the ordering.

 

[Big Daddy]

Just looked it up.

Nothing in rules about being down if you are laying on top of another offensive player who is down.

You are wrong, Mr Cyclone.

 

[Clonestar85]

Sounds like BS to me. How does a QB sneak ever work ? Often the OLman's on the ground or at least his knee is on the ground and the QB is on top of him. They let that go and don't call the QB down.
Fox rules expert didn't have a problem with being on the OLman. I'll trust him over you.
Go back to your cornfield.

Easy there sport, just check the rules

 

[TheMonkey]

Just looked it up.

Nothing in rules about being down if you are laying on top of another offensive player who is down.

You are wrong, Mr Cyclone.

Easy there sport, just check the rules

 

[Clonestar85]

Just looked it up.

Nothing in rules about being down if you are laying on top of another offensive player who is down.

You are wrong, Mr Cyclone.

I have looked and I can’t find it either. I did find this. Article 3 sec 2b was an obvious violation and it appears they may have decided to claim forward progress stopped where your OL grabbed and pulled the ball carrier(which was on view for everyone to see). They are supposed to throw a flag on that which I believe would have given another play after assessment.

https://imgur.com/a/y5Zw1iN

 

[Big Daddy]

Yup, agree that pulling isn't allowed but when they review a spot they don't look for other rules violations.
Any replay review is specific to the point in question and not an open look at everything that went on in the play.

 

[Clonestar85]

Yup, agree that pulling isn't allowed but when they review a spot they don't look for other rules violations.
Any replay review is specific to the point in question and not an open look at everything that went on in the play.

Rematch in Dallas would be appropriate. Both of these teams are banged up after Sat. That was the hardest hitting game so far in conference

 

[cowboys_r_us]

Btw you never see that called. Never happens. Same can be said for the BS celebration penalty.

Cyclone fans need to run along and enjoy their time in the sun. The cupboard (players and coaches) is going to be bare next year.

 

[Clonestar85]

Btw you never see that called. Never happens. Same can be said for the BS celebration penalty.

Cyclone fans need to run along and enjoy their time in the sun. The cupboard (players and coaches) is going to be bare next year.

Simply not true as depth is good. Outside folks just see losses of marquee players and assume big drop offs. I am surprised an OSU fan would make such a statement as it happens exactly that way in Stillwater

 

[TheMonkey]

Simply not true as depth is good. Outside folks just see losses of marquee players and assume big drop offs. I am surprised an OSU fan would make such a statement as it happens exactly that way in Stillwater

I don’t have an intimate knowledge of your depth, but it does seem like a prime opportunity for Campbell to make a move. Losing Purdy and Kolar seems to create questions about future success. The experience and intangibles aren’t easy to replace.

 

[Clonestar85]

I don’t have an intimate knowledge of your depth, but it does seem like a prime opportunity for Campbell to make a move. Losing Purdy and Kolar seems to create questions about future success. The experience and intangibles aren’t easy to replace.

He contemplated a move to the Browns last year, but ultimately his family decided that Ames is where they wanted to be. I don’t believe he is going anywhere anytime soon.

 

[Coolfogg]

Simply not true as depth is good. Outside folks just see losses of marquee players and assume big drop offs. I am surprised an OSU fan would make such a statement as it happens exactly that way in Stillwater

Purdy and Kolar is a lot to replace.

 

[OSU9953]

With the transfer portal, a couple high end transfers could keep ISU afloat pretty easily. The job Campbell has done, I’m sure there’s some high end prospects that would highly consider playing for him.

 

[Clonestar85]

Purdy and Kolar is a lot to replace.

QB room is strong and another Purdy type is coming in. Kolar will be missed but there are very talented TEs in the program.

 

[TheMonkey]

He contemplated a move to the Browns last year, but ultimately his family decided that Ames is where they wanted to be. I don’t believe he is going anywhere anytime soon.

Maybe, but that’s been a common refrain before a coach got a better offer and bolted. Campbell is fairly young and has no real ties to Ames that I can tell. Turning down consideration for the Browns while he still had Purdy and Kolar does not necessarily mean he’s locked down at ISU. There will be a lot of prominent openings for him to consider. Timing is everything.

 

[cowboys_r_us]

Got it, so the QB who's set 31 school records is going to be replaced next year, at Iowa State. Lol.

And while you're at it, replace :
TE -Kolar, Chase Allen
WR- Hutchison, Milton
LB- Rose, Hummel, Vance
DB- Elsworth, Johnson
Punter/Kicker -Mevis

You're hoping you'll keep your coaches and be competitive again in 2024-2025.

 

[Clonestar85]

Maybe, but that’s been a common refrain before a coach got a better offer and bolted. Campbell is fairly young and has no real ties to Ames that I can tell. Turning down consideration for the Browns while he still had Purdy and Kolar does not necessarily mean he’s locked down at ISU. There will be a lot of prominent openings for him to consider. Timing is everything.

He has a young family and they want to raise them in a good safe environment. Ames fits that bill to a T. He asked that his coordinators and coaches get the highest % of raises so the coordinators got bumped to $1M each. Other coaches were rewarded as well. Campbell is not $$$ driven. The college jobs that he would leave for are Ohio St & ND.

 

[cowboys_r_us]

I'd be glad to see ISU beat OU and would be happy to have a chance to meet in Arlington. Unfortunately though, as an OSU fan I'm forced to stare reality in the face often and in this case it's clear that this is "the year" for Iowa State.

 

[Clonestar85]

I'd be glad to see ISU beat OU and would be happy to have a chance to meet in Arlington. Unfortunately though, as an OSU fan I'm forced to stare reality in the face often and in this case it's clear that this is "the year" for Iowa State.

We can win in Norman. We lost by 1 by going for two on the last trip, and won by 7 over Mayfield the time before. We aren’t intimidated playing there. And hopefully, there are many more years for ISU.

 

[Big Daddy]

He has a young family and they want to raise them in a good safe environment. Ames fits that bill to a T. He asked that his coordinators and coaches get the highest % of raises so the coordinators got bumped to $1M each. Other coaches were rewarded as well. Campbell is not $$$ driven. The college jobs that he would leave for are Ohio St & ND.

• Defensive coordinator Jon Heacock: $925,000.
• Offensive coordinator Tom Manning: $925,000

Campbell makes $3M/yr
Turned down 8 yrs $69M from Lions. So, ya, not $$ driven