Been meaning to post on this thread for a while to add my two cents as a fellow enjoyer of the spirit of choice. I know all drinks are to-each- their own, so here are my thoughts on what is in my cabinet. Ranked from the top down as to what I enjoy the most. For reference, my palate prefers less bite/harshness in my whiskey and bourbons most of the time. Also, I don't drink very often, so some of the bottles in our cabinets have a little dust...
Jack Daniel's Sinatra Select - So smooth, so good. Comes in a a crystal bottle too, fancy, I know and expensive, though not on the Pappy's level. Great sipping with a rock or two.
Blantons (not shown in the pic.) - Recently tried this, and o-baby, good stuff. Great flavor and mostly smooth overall. Opened and tried last night for the first time so recency bias has it near the top of my list.
Jim Beam Signature Craft - This is a great one that was buried at the back of the shelf. I forgot how good it was until just the other day when I pulled everything out while cleaning.
Bib & Tucker - This is my favorite modestly priced sipper. Very smooth and some good after-note flavors. I always recommend this to anyone who may be a novice in whiskey department. Also, it has a pretty cool bottle.
Wild Turkey Long Branch - Randomly picked this up and have enjoyed it so far. As still smooth like the previous ones noted above, but starting to get into a bit of a bite.
Crown Royal Monarch 75th (not in the pic) - Pretty solid and smooth from our friends to the north. I actually haven't had this one in a while, so I need a memory refresher asap.
Makers Cask Strength - I really like this one cut with a touch of water or melted cubes. Has a little more bite than I prefer, straight up.
Knob Creek Single Barrel - Getting more "spicy" as we move down the list. Good mixing agent, but again. more bite than I like straight.
Jim Beam Single Barrel /
Jack Single Barrel - These are pretty similar in my opinion, though I want to get everything out again here soon and do a tasting to compare and refresh the palate. Both have a good bite to them and work better as mixers (for me) as a result.
Jim Beam Brown Rice (no longer available) - A few years ago JB did a limited run/signature series of a few different things (Rye, Brown Rice, etc. don't recall the other flavors) My favorite whiskey of all time is that Brown Rice. I don't know what it was (as it was 5 to 8-ish years ago), but hot damn it was good. After the limited run, i spent more time online and call around than I would prefer to admit, trying to find a box.
Random Thoughts - In general, just having a few drinks with friends, plain old Jack or Jim are very reasonably priced options to mix or have with a few cubes. Rye's are ok for me sometimes. Templeton's Rye is probably the best one of those I have tried. Still haven't tried any Pappy's yet, and I don't know how intrigued I am to even pay for a shot knowing I can get a full bottle of something for the same price. That said, I'm sure I'll bite the bullet and fork over the $ if I ever come across it. My experience at a couple of whiskey tastings have told me I'm not a fan of the 4 Roses brand for whatever reason. Side note, my wife found some honey that had been stored/aged in a whiskey barrel. Yes. If you are on this thread b/c you like the drinks discussed, I would recommend trying to find it or something to the like.